Guess the weight 2

Cap'n Fishy

Well-known member
Sep 29, 2008
I was out for loch sea trout this week, on what I suspect was the same water that the fish in the 'Guess the weight' thread was taken from. With that in the back of my mind, and it seeming the first thread had been disowned, I thought if I get a decent fish I'll have a go at a Mark 2 version of it.

Well, jeezo... it turned into 3 of the hardest days fishing I have had in a long time. The water was low and nearly 19 C. What's it doing being 19 C in late August in the far north of Scotland??? :oops: To make matters worse, we were in a massive high pressure, centred over Scotland! We had spells with cloud, but zero wind, and we had spells of breeze, but with zero cloud.

Well, you just have to give it your best shot, eh? And we did. But after 2 and a half days of trying all sorts, I was coming to the conclusion that the best shot was to focus on the dap. The majority of fish coming to the dap had been tyre-kickers and window-shoppers, but at least we were seeing them. Fishing wets seemed like fishing without flies on! So, here we were on the last day. Even though my boat partner had taken 2 sea trout in the morning on wet fly, and I was staring down the barrel of a grannie, I decided to pin my faith in the dap. The breeze was stuttering by mid afternoon. I had the 'Red Lady daddy' on (identifies as LGBT+ :whistle:). With it only a few feet in front of me, a salmon appeared out of nowhere and made a play at it. I could see it had missed, and I managed to hold the fly in the zone in case it would have another go. And it did. And it took it and went down with it. I gave it the customary 'biff', which either results in zero resistance and an exclamation, or results in solid resistance and a fish hooked. This met with solid resistance... my heart soared... for one second... after which the fly catapulted up into the air! My heart sank! Strong words were uttered. :mad:

I carried on...

The Red Lady dapping fly was getting soggy now, and increasingly difficult to keep on top like thistledown. So, I went for a change, and for no reason decided to swap it for an old favourite, Fred Astaire...

This proved a good move, as the next 2 hours saw 3 good sea trout take it confidently and end up in the net.

Here are the 3 fish...

Fish 1


Fish 2


Fish 3


Grannie saved, and to some extent the trip saved... though it would have been good to stay attached to the salmon.

So, to give a bit of a test of your judgment skills...

What is the combined weight of the 3 fish above?

No prizes on offer - just the kudos to be the one who gets it right.

I have sent a report of the trip to 3 members of this forum. They will know who they are and are barred from guessing. 😜 But they will be able to confirm the weight when someone guesses right.

Last edited:


Well-known member
Mar 21, 2008
6lbs 2ozs for the three, you won’t disappear will you like morangiedave 😁
Last edited:


Well-known member
Aug 24, 2008
What, for all 3, put together? :oops:

They're not lean. Just torpedo-shaped. 😉

Yeah, all three. First one if it was lifted with one hand would look around 2lbs. Second and third hard to tell, don't know the net but judging by the flies about one and quarter each so I'll update to four and a half pounds for the three.

Not having a pop at the quality of the fish but by weight to length on these ones that i see as tending to be a touch lean, brings my total down.

I gave up weighing fish a long time ago as being unreliable with what I was using. My estimates using experience were judged by others as being too high so now I err on the low side.