Excellent thread this one! I’m am really really fussy when I’m buying a reel. I want it black or at least not too bling and shiny. I want it to be a workhorse that’ll last me years. I don’t want over engineering on it. I also prefer a classic look. My still water trout reels tend to have been cassettes like BFR and Orvis clearwaters. Price of spools and the amount of lines I carry dictate this. Same applies to my pike reels.
When it comes to rivers and other species I’ve bought and sold a fair few reels over the years. Nothing stupidly high end as I’ve never been able to justify £500+ on a reel.
I have drifted between click pawl and different drags but it’s not really a deal breaker either way for me.
Reels I’ve loved....
Original Orvis battenkill LA made in England. (Should never have sold this yin)
Vosseler DC 2
Battenkill disc
Sage click
Old Marquis #5
I am currently using a Danielsson dry fly for my #5 river stuff. Bought it not long ago and I’ve got to say I love it. Right up my street and delighted with the purchase. I’ll be investing in a FW next year for my sea troot fishing.
Some I’ve hated....
Greys GRX
Lamson Liquid
Another model lamson I can’t remember. Lightweight and made of cardboard!
The wish list.....
I have always fancied a custom Abel.
For the salmon I’d like a loop classic or one from Murray Stewart.
Tight lines
Paul