Statement: Joint Fisheries Conservation NGO Position on Eurasian Beaver Reintroduction into England and Wales

Editor

Fish&Fly
Staff member
Joined
Jun 8, 2009
Messages
4,139
Location
Brighton, UK
Issued by the Atlantic Salmon Trust

{feed:pubdate}

Fighting to protect our iconic and threatened migratory fish.​


AST, along with fisheries conservations organisations: Salmon and Trout Conservation, Game and Wildlife Conservation Trust, The Angling Trust, the River Otter Fisheries Association, and the South West Rivers Association, have raised concerns to the UK and Welsh government, the Environment Agency, Natural Resources Wales and Natural England that, too often, beaver introductions are taking place without a proper assessment on the impact on fish, and without a proper long-term management plan to avoid harm, particularly to species such as salmon, whose status has reached a critical point.

The full position on the introduction of beavers is available below.

Fish-NGO-Beavers-Management-Strategy-Policy-StatementDownload



The post Statement: Joint Fisheries Conservation NGO Position on Eurasian Beaver Reintroduction into England and Wales appeared first on The Atlantic Salmon Trust.

Source Website
 

bobfly2

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 11, 2015
Messages
404
The Times reports today that beavers will probably be given protected status and could then be released in England without containment.
So Scotland will have a very ready export location for its unwanted surplus, aside from their legally shot 90 p.a. at last report.
No indication given of a damage compensation scheme.
 

aenoon

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 12, 2009
Messages
12,941
Location
Linlithgow, Scotland and anywhere i can wet a line
The Times reports today that beavers will probably be given protected status and could then be released in England without containment.
So Scotland will have a very ready export location for its unwanted surplus, aside from their legally shot 90 p.a. at last report.
No indication given of a damage compensation scheme.
Like we are going to trap them and send to England?
You at the wind up here?
 

kingf000

Well-known member
Joined
Jun 13, 2016
Messages
2,080
I was watching a programme on the tele recently where beavers had blocked a culvert running under a railway line, flooding the area around the track, making it more likely for the railway embankment to collapse. I just wonder how many other issues will arise with these harmless creatures in the future?
 

bobfly2

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 11, 2015
Messages
404
Like we are going to trap them and send to England?
You at the wind up here?
Not at all. Beavers have been caught from Tayside and shipped to other locations for some time. About 90 others were shot last year.
 

diawl bach

Well-known member
Joined
May 17, 2006
Messages
8,366
Germany has a compensation scheme for the damage reintroduced beavers cause
I was watching a programme on the tele recently where beavers had blocked a culvert running under a railway line, flooding the area around the track, making it more likely for the railway embankment to collapse. I just wonder how many other issues will arise with these harmless creatures in the future?

Looking at the compensation scheme established in Bavaria there needs to be a fund for dealing with the problems they cause in the UK , odd this hasn't been addressed ( from 2017 ) -

There are now around 30,000 beavers across Germany, 20,000 of them in Bavaria alone.

For farmers, the semiaquatic rodents are like a “plague”, writes Die Welt – they cause fields and meadows to be plunged under water, and they cut down trees to build their homes. Bavaria provides €450,000 annually to make up for the damage.
 

diawl bach

Well-known member
Joined
May 17, 2006
Messages
8,366
Bit more info, 100+ requested from Scotland for "trials" across England. For trials read " escape locations".
Exporting the beavers looks better than lethal control I suppose but eventually the reintroduction programmes will either walk away from the aftermath of their work or be forced into shooting beavers to control them.
 

bobfly2

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 11, 2015
Messages
404
This is what has happened in Scotland. An official trial in Kintyre with a dozen lost half to mortality and more were added. Elsewhere in Tayside dozens were managing to "escape" from property and there are now many hundreds with about 90 declared shot each year and dozens being relocated to England and Wales. Training courses are held marksmen and landowners' damage increases. Beaver activity now takes up a considerable amount of river warden workload.
 

Fly cast

Active member
Joined
Mar 19, 2021
Messages
25
Location
East Ayrshire
All river fishing should be catch and release, we all need to do our bit to give our waters an helping hand through the hardest times that our waters are going through with over fishing, pollution, global warming, large amounts estrogen from contraception pill creating an imbalance in fish stocks, its not one thing but a combination of many.
 

scotsmac

Well-known member
Joined
Jul 17, 2009
Messages
61
All river fishing should be catch and release, we all need to do our bit to give our waters an helping hand through the hardest times that our waters are going through with over fishing, pollution, global warming, large amounts estrogen from contraception pill creating an imbalance in fish stocks, its not one thing but a combination of many.
I in some way think c/r has done more harm than good.
It for sure will never be a method to increase our stock. And the killing of Salmon threw trapping or an angler chapping a fish has never been the cause of salmon decline.
Their was no shortage of fish when we had nets all over estuary, The Sea, and in River. The rivers were bouncing with fish 50 years ago, and we killed everything.
But as our dirty footprint has got worse and worse, the numbers get less and less. It not rocket science. Clean the water the fish will do the rest.
C/R gives the power to be a perfect excuse to do nothing meaningful in restoring the stock. Making someone feel guilty for taking a fish, when the probably buy salmon from supermarket.
If we all put our energy into highlighting the big destroyers. Fish Farms. Raw Sewage poured straight in, Farmers chemicals, ( WE don't even know what crap they pump in now, theirs so many, Forestry commission, 1st the Drainage, 2nd the bog 1. Planting these trees, near the headwater has turned a 1 time nursery for spring fish into an ACID tank. Was anything done . Well bit bla bla, some money into wrong hands, and the acid pit remains.
These are our issues , and they need dealing with or the end will approach.
Take Russia, Iceland, these fish go same sea , and their no shortage fish their.
We need concentrate on these issues, just 1 of them and not stop till a solution is put on table.
C/R gives authorities the prefect excuse to side step the main issues, and present c/r in the name of conservation.
The Dee not bad example.
Would love to see out of interest bring the Dee back to kill policy, and see if the stock goes down. I think it will make 0 difference,
In my opinion it best smoke screen ever, and we near all buying into it.
 

Latest posts

Top